Add-backs that don't hold up
“One-time” expenses that recur every year, personal costs run through the business, and add-backs with no invoice, receipt, or bank record behind them.
I'm Matan Cohen, founder of QoE Direct. This is what I do — full-time, every day. When you're about to put your name — and your loan — on a business, someone with no stake in the deal should check the seller's numbers first. That's my job: I test every add-back and trace the earnings back to bank statements and tax returns, and my CPA partner reviews and signs the report.
SBA 7(a) loans on acquisitions of $3M+ now require an independent Quality of Earnings report — our Comprehensive package is prepared in SBA lender-ready format, so the same report that protects your price can satisfy your lender.
Most small-business listings present “adjusted” earnings. Some adjustments are legitimate. Many are optimistic, incomplete, or impossible to verify from the package you were given. A Quality of Earnings (QoE) review separates the two — before your money is committed.
“One-time” expenses that recur every year, personal costs run through the business, and add-backs with no invoice, receipt, or bank record behind them.
Vehicles, insurance, travel, family on payroll, and a below-market owner salary. If you'll have to replace that labor at market rate, the earnings change.
A single large project, a customer about to leave, or a spike year presented as the trend. We look at three years — not just the best one.
When 40–60% of revenue sits with two or three customers, you're not buying a business — you're buying their loyalty. Concentration risk changes the price and the structure.
Why it matters in dollars: Small businesses trade on a multiple of earnings. Every $50,000 of overstated EBITDA at a 3× multiple is $150,000 you overpay — plus a larger loan, larger payments, and less cash left to run the business.
See the packages ↓Big accounting firms and diligence boutiques are set up for private-equity transactions, not $300K–$5M acquisitions. Their minimum fees can swallow your entire diligence budget — so most buyers at this level skip verification completely and close on numbers nobody independent has ever checked. This practice exists for exactly the deals those firms won't take.
| Who prepares it | Typical cost |
|---|---|
| Big 4 & regional CPA firms | $20,000+ |
| Mid-market diligence boutiques | $8,000–$15,000 |
| QoE Direct | from $3,500 |
Same analysis the big firms sell — priced for deals under $5M, where their minimum fees don't make sense.
Five steps from first conversation to a report you can act on, built around your closing deadline.
A 20-minute call about your deal. We'll give you an honest assessment of whether a Quality of Earnings review makes sense for it — and if it doesn't, we'll tell you that too. No sales pitch.
20 minutes · FreePick Standard or Comprehensive in the onboarding below and pay securely by card through Stripe. The full fee is paid before any work begins — no deposits, no balance due later.
Paid in full via StripeWe email your engagement letter and a private, secure upload link. You upload the seller's P&Ls, tax returns, and bank statements — under NDA — and we confirm by email when your file is complete.
Private upload link · By emailI build the full analysis personally — every add-back tested against source documents — then my CPA partner, a licensed CPA, reviews the findings and signs off on the report.
Reviewed & signed by our CPA partnerYour report arrives by email, followed by a walkthrough call covering the verdict, what it means for your price, and your options — renegotiate, restructure, or walk away.
Delivered by emailBoth packages cover the complete scope below — an analysis reviewed and signed by our CPA partner, written so a first-time buyer can act on it, and detailed enough for a lender or broker to take seriously.
Three years of P&Ls, balance sheets, and cash flow statements reviewed for accuracy, consistency, and reliability — the foundation everything else is built on.
A line-by-line bridge from reported profit to verified earnings. Every seller add-back is tested against source documents — accepted, reduced, or rejected, with the reason stated.
Reported revenue is traced to actual bank deposits. If the money didn't hit the bank, it doesn't count as earnings.
Recurring vs. one-time revenue, growth pattern, and gross margin by year — and whether the most recent year is representative or a spike.
Monthly performance reviewed across the period to surface seasonality, one-off anomalies, and recent deterioration that annual totals can hide.
Top-customer share of revenue and profit, contract status, and what losing the largest customer would do to cash flow.
The owner's total pay and perks measured against the market cost of hiring a replacement manager to do the same job — so earnings reflect life after the sale.
Operating expenses screened for unusual, non-recurring, or personal items that won't transfer to a new owner — and for necessary costs the seller left out.
How much cash the business actually needs to operate day to day, what a normal level looks like at closing, and who should fund any gap.
Unrecorded payables, deferred revenue, equipment obligations, and other off-P&L items that should reduce the price you pay.
The books are tied to filed tax returns, with sales-tax, payroll-tax, and other compliance exposure flagged. Where the numbers disagree, we show you where — and by how much.
Page one, in plain English: what we verified, what we couldn't, what it means for price and structure, and our overall assessment.
Every report ends with a walkthrough call where we go through the findings, the price implications, and your options — renegotiate, restructure, or walk away — in plain language.
See pricingPick by deal size — that's the only decision. Both packages cover the full 12-item scope, both are reviewed and signed by our CPA partner, and both are paid in full before work begins. No hourly billing, no deposits, no balance due later.
The complete Quality of Earnings report for smaller acquisitions.
Flat fee · Paid in full upfront · No work begins until payment is received
Not in SBA format. Using an SBA loan? Choose Comprehensive.
Book a Free Deal ReviewThe deeper report — three years of analysis in the format SBA lenders expect.
Flat fee · Paid in full upfront · No work begins until payment is received
For larger acquisitions and complex situations that don't fit a flat-fee package.
Quoted per deal · Scoped on the free deal review call · Paid in full before work begins, once quoted
Lender-ready, or we rework it free. If your lender requires revisions to your report's format or scope, we revise it at no additional charge.
Payment policy: Your report fee is paid in full before work begins. No analysis starts — and no findings are shared — until payment is received. If we decline your engagement after intake, your fee is refunded in full. Not sure which package fits? Choose “Not sure yet” in the onboarding and start with the free deal review call — we'll recommend the right one for your deal.
Plenty of firms can read a P&L. Very few are built specifically for the person buying a small business with their own money and their own loan. We are.
Acquisitions from $300K to $5M are all we do — nothing else. No seller-side work, no broker engagements, no private-equity overflow. Every process, checklist, and price in this practice is built for deals your size.
Every report is independently reviewed and signed by our CPA partner, a licensed CPA who is part of every engagement. You get an operator's analysis with a licensed professional's signature on it — the combination lenders take seriously.
This practice was founded by a business operator, and the founder works your deal personally — first call to final report. No account managers, no hand-offs, and nobody whose bonus depends on your deal closing.
Traditional firms take three to six weeks, when they'll take a small deal at all. Our reports land in 10 business days or less from a complete file — built around your exclusivity window and closing deadline, not our queue.
QoE Direct isn't a call center or a platform. It's a founder-led practice — you know exactly who is doing the work, and who is signing it.
Every report is independently reviewed and signed by Matan's CPA partner, a licensed CPA who is part of every engagement. Matan builds the analysis; his partner provides the licensed professional review and sign-off — that's the standard your lender expects. Two sets of eyes, one accountable team, on every report.
Matan Cohen is a St. Louis, Missouri–based entrepreneur who built his career owning and operating service businesses. Years of sitting on both sides of the table — running companies day to day, and evaluating businesses to buy — taught him exactly how seller numbers get dressed up: generous add-backs that recur every year, owner perks buried in operating expenses, family on payroll, a below-market owner salary, and revenue presented as recurring when it isn't. He reads a P&L the way an owner does — payroll, materials, trucks, insurance, and all the places profit quietly leaks out — because that's the world he comes from.
He kept meeting the same buyer. Someone buying in the $300K–$5M range — a first-time buyer, a searcher, an operator buying out a partner — who did the responsible thing and asked a traditional firm for a Quality of Earnings report, and was quoted $8,000 to $20,000 or more. More than their entire diligence budget. So they skipped it, and closed on numbers nobody independent had ever checked. He built QoE Direct to fix that: to give buyers at this level the same financial clarity private equity gets on every deal, at a flat price that actually fits the deal — $3,500 or $4,900, not five figures.
QoE Direct is his focus. This isn't a side project and it isn't one of several things he splits his time across — it's the work in front of him, every day. He works every engagement personally, from the first free deal-review call through the analysis to the final report and walkthrough. No account managers, no hand-offs, no junior analyst learning on your deal. When you hire QoE Direct, you get Matan — and his CPA partner's licensed review and signature on the finished report. No stake in your deal closing. No stake in it dying. Just the verified number, and what it means for your price.
St. Louis is home. Matan lives there with his fiancée, Caitlin, and their cat, Phoenix — and serves buyers nationwide, remotely, from his office in St. Louis.
Short, plain-English guides on how Quality of Earnings reviews work, what to watch for in a seller's numbers, and how to run diligence on a small-business purchase. No email required — read them right here.
What a QoE report actually checks, how it differs from an audit, and the deals where skipping one turns into the most expensive mistake of the purchase.
Add-backs decide what you pay. Which ones are legitimate, which ones deserve a hard look, and how every $10,000 of them moves your purchase price.
Earnings set the price — so verified earnings set a fair one. How a report pays for itself in renegotiation, deal structure, and the purchases you walk away from.
The documents to request, the questions the numbers should answer, the people to have on your side, and the red flags to catch before your exclusivity window closes.
Price is only one of five things you're actually buying. A five-dimension framework — financial quality, operational resilience, commercial strength, owner dependency, and personal fit — for judging a business before you put a number on it.
Buyer guide · The basics · About 6 minutes
When you buy a business, you are not really buying its equipment, its name, or its customer list. You are buying its earnings — the stream of profit the business produces year after year. The purchase price is almost always calculated as a multiple of those earnings, which means everything depends on one question: are the earnings the seller is showing you real?
A Quality of Earnings (QoE) report is an independent analysis that answers that question. It takes the seller's claimed profit apart, tests it against source documents, and rebuilds it into a verified number you can price a deal on.
A proper QoE review works from primary evidence — bank statements, filed tax returns, payroll records — not from the seller's summary spreadsheet. Among other things, it:
The output is an adjusted EBITDA figure you can defend — to yourself, to a partner, and to a lender — plus a plain-English summary of what was verified, what could not be, and what it means for the price.
An audit is a formal opinion on whether financial statements follow accounting standards, prepared for broad audiences like investors and regulators. It is slow, expensive, and not designed around your decision. A QoE review is the opposite: narrow, fast, and built for one buyer making one decision. It is also different from having your accountant glance at the seller's tax returns. A return shows what was reported to the IRS; it does not show whether revenue reached the bank, whether "one-time" expenses recur every year, or whether the business can support the debt you're about to sign for.
You almost certainly do if the price is based on "adjusted" earnings or SDE with a list of add-backs, if you're borrowing to buy (SBA 7(a) acquisitions of $3M or more now require an independent QoE report), if you're buying with partners whose money is also at stake, or if anything about the numbers feels unusually clean. You might reasonably skip it on a small asset purchase priced on equipment value rather than earnings — or when the seller finances most of the price and your exposure is genuinely small. If you're unsure, that's exactly what a free deal review call is for: a good QoE provider will tell you when you don't need one.
The bottom line: the report costs a flat, known fee. Guessing wrong about earnings costs a multiple of the error, every year, for as long as you own the business. Verify first — then negotiate.
Buying a business and want a second set of eyes on the numbers before you commit?
Book a free deal reviewBuyer guide · Seller numbers · About 6 minutes
Few terms in a business sale matter more — or get abused more — than the add-back. Understanding them is the difference between paying for a business's real earnings and paying for its owner's lifestyle.
An add-back is an expense the seller adds back to the business's profit, arguing it won't exist once you own the business. Start with the profit on the books, add back a list of these items, and you get the "adjusted earnings" — SDE or adjusted EBITDA — that the asking price is based on. Because price is earnings multiplied (commonly two to four times for small businesses), every add-back dollar is multiplied too. A $40,000 add-back at a 3× multiple is $120,000 of purchase price.
The rule is simple: every add-back needs a source document. An invoice, a bank or card record, a payroll register, a contract. In a Quality of Earnings review, each add-back on the seller's schedule is tested against that evidence and marked accepted, reduced, or rejected — with the reason written down. Add-backs that can't be documented don't count, and the adjusted earnings fall to what the evidence supports.
A rule of thumb for your own first pass: for every add-back, ask, "Will this cost exist, in some form, the month after I own this business?" If the honest answer is yes, it isn't an add-back — it's an expense, and you should be pricing the deal as if you'll pay it. Because you will.
Got a seller's add-back schedule you'd like tested line by line?
See the report packagesBuyer guide · The math · About 5 minutes
Buyers sometimes hesitate at the cost of a Quality of Earnings report. That's understandable — until you run the math on what the report is actually protecting. Small businesses are priced as a multiple of earnings. That single fact means small errors in earnings become large errors in price.
Take an illustrative example. A seller claims $600,000 of adjusted EBITDA, and the business is priced at a 3× multiple: $1,800,000. A QoE review finds $90,000 of add-backs that can't be documented and an owner salary $40,000 below the cost of replacing him — verified earnings of $470,000. At the same multiple, the supportable price is $1,410,000. The gap is $390,000 — against a report fee of a few thousand dollars. Even a modest finding pays: every $10,000 of overstated earnings at 3× is $30,000 you would have overpaid, plus the interest on borrowing it.
There's a quieter benefit: lenders underwrite verified numbers faster and with fewer conditions. An SBA lender-ready QoE report gives the bank exactly the analysis its credit committee wants, in the format it expects — and for SBA 7(a) acquisitions of $3M or more, an independent report is now required anyway. Deals stall when lenders start asking questions nobody can answer; a report answers them before they're asked.
The bottom line: the fee is flat, fixed, and known before you start. The cost of unverified earnings is none of those things. On any deal where the price rests on the seller's adjusted numbers, verification is the cheapest money in the transaction.
Want the math run on your deal before you sign?
Book a free deal reviewBuyer guide · Diligence · About 6 minutes
Diligence windows are short — often 30 to 60 days — and the buyers who get the best answers are the ones who ask for the right things on day one. Use this checklist to organize your request list and your thinking. (It's a reading list, not homework: your job is to request and review; verifying the numbers is what a QoE engagement is for.)
Three, ideally before you sign a purchase agreement: a QoE provider to verify the earnings, a transaction attorney to paper the deal and its protections, and your lender, engaged early enough that their requirements shape your diligence instead of ambushing it at the end.
The bottom line: diligence isn't about distrusting the seller — it's about pricing reality. Request everything early, verify what the price is based on, and let the findings shape the offer. That sequence is the whole game.
In a diligence window now? Start with a free 20-minute review of your deal.
Book a free deal reviewBuyer guide · Before the offer · About 5 minutes
Most buyers evaluate a business with a single comparison: asking price versus claimed earnings. That comparison matters — but a purchase is really five separate bets bundled into one, and a business can pass the price test while failing several of the others. Before you make an offer, score the business on five dimensions. A weakness in any one of them doesn't automatically kill a deal — but it should change the price, the structure, or both.
Start where the money is. Look at three years, not one: is revenue growing, flat, or quietly shrinking? Are margins stable, or did the most recent year benefit from something unusual? Most importantly, can the claimed profit be traced to evidence — bank deposits, filed tax returns, payroll records? Earnings that can't be documented aren't earnings; they're a claim, and claims shouldn't be priced as facts. This is the dimension a Quality of Earnings review tests directly, and it's the one every other judgment depends on, because the price is a multiple of this number.
A business that only works when everything goes right is worth less than one that absorbs bad weeks. Ask how work actually gets done: are processes written down or carried in people's heads? Is anyone cross-trained, or does one absence stop production? What condition is the equipment in, and what capital spending lands in your first two years? Check the unglamorous systems too — scheduling, invoicing, collections. Fragility is risk, and risk belongs in the price.
Revenue quality matters as much as revenue size. How much comes from repeat customers, contracts, or recurring services versus one-off jobs that must be re-won every month? How concentrated is it — if the top customer is a third of sales, you're partly buying that relationship. Look at reputation as an asset: reviews, referrals, and standing in the local market take years to build and transfer with the business. A slightly smaller business with durable, diversified revenue is usually the better purchase.
List everything the owner personally does: selling, quoting, the skilled work itself, the bookkeeping, the customer relationships. Then ask what each item costs to replace — in salary, in time, or in revenue that walks out the door. If customers call the owner's personal cell phone and the owner is the only licensed operator, you may be buying a demanding job with a transition problem attached. The remedies are structural: a paid transition period, a proper non-compete, training commitments, or an earn-out tied to customer retention.
The dimension buyers skip, because it isn't in the financial package. Can you do — or credibly hire for — the core work? Do the hours, the physical demands, the licensing requirements, and the week-to-week reality of the job fit your life? And does the math fit: can the verified cash flow service your loan, pay you a market wage, and still leave a cushion? A business that fails the fit test becomes a bad purchase at almost any price, because you'll be the one living inside it.
Rate each dimension strong, acceptable, or weak — based on evidence, not impressions. One weak dimension is a negotiating point. Two or more is a signal that the price or the structure has to compensate you for real risk — or that the right move is to walk away and keep looking. Bring the list into your offer: documented findings justify working-capital terms, seller financing, transition support, and contingencies far better than a vague sense that the price "feels high."
The bottom line: an offer made after a five-dimension evaluation isn't just a number — it's a number with reasons behind it. Sellers and brokers can argue with an opinion. They have a much harder time arguing with evidence.
Evaluating a business right now? Get a second set of eyes on the financial dimension before you offer.
Book a free deal reviewTell us about you and the deal, then either choose your package and pay in full securely — or pick “Not sure yet” and start with the free deal review call. No work begins until payment is received in full. From there, everything runs by email — engagement letter, document uploads, updates, and your final report — so you always have a complete written record.
Start with the free deal review
Confidential — seller financials are handled under NDA. · Acquisitions from $500K to $5M, nationwide; reviews are done remotely.
Important disclosure: QoE Direct is a consulting firm, not a CPA firm. Reports are financial due-diligence analyses prepared for the buyer's decision-making and are not an audit, review, or compilation of financial statements. CPA review and sign-off on every report is provided by our CPA partner, a licensed CPA. Figures shown in examples on this page are illustrative only.